Safen Roy

Essays · · 6 min read

The Years Between Attempts

We give rather different accounts of our lives depending on whether someone asks how long we have been doing something or how often we do it. The answer to the first question might be twenty years. The second takes a little explaining. There were whole evenings once, then a period when work took up most of the week. There was a year when we became interested in something else. We came back to it for a while last winter.

“Consistency is key” belongs to the considerable body of advice we learn to repeat before we have lived long enough to have an opinion about it. An elder says it to a child, who receives it with the mild impatience due to something fairly obvious. Years later the child says it to someone younger and discovers, in the course of saying it, that they believe it. They probably also know a little more by then about the kind of week in which a person can fail to do a single thing they meant to do.

That is what makes the advice worth another look. We understand it readily enough over the length of a school term. Over thirty or forty years, it becomes an interesting question what, exactly, we imagine a person has kept doing.

Some of us first had the freedom to find these things out in the less supervised hours of an afternoon. On an early internet connection, we could set something to download, go and eat, come back, and find there was still time to become interested in something else. A word we had seen in passing might occupy the better part of the wait.

We would read an exchange between people who seemed to know one another, understand perhaps half of what they were discussing, and follow the one part that made sense. By the time the file arrived, we occasionally wanted to finish what we were reading.

It would be generous to call this a method of learning. We were quite capable of wasting an afternoon and, given the opportunity, doing much the same the next day. Yet a few things became familiar through those hours. We learned to look a little further down a discussion after the first confident answer. We began to recognise the person who had actually tried what they were suggesting. There was a particular relief in coming across somebody willing to say which part they still couldn’t explain. Long before we had much reason to consider how we decided whom to trust, we had acquired preferences.

The machines we learned on are gone. If any files survive, their dates give a surprisingly detailed account of several evenings and leave the next six years entirely blank. I used to read that blank as the place where nothing happened. A machine keeps state. It does not keep what the state did to us. Those years left no timestamps, and yet something was deposited in them. We became someone who knows, without quite being told, when a question is going to cost an evening.

A machine keeps state. It does not keep what the state did to us.

Interests do disappear. At fifteen we can care enormously about a subject that scarcely crosses our minds at thirty. It seems a little too convenient, looking back, to put every enthusiasm to work on behalf of the future. Some of those evenings were spent in good company, one or two with someone we were falling in love with, some in fairly questionable company, and some alone. We enjoyed ourselves. It would have surprised us at the time to learn that an account of the evening’s contribution to our development might eventually be required.

Machines are very good at streaks. A counter can tell us we have kept something up for four hundred days, or that the chain is broken, and it treats the two as the whole account. Continuity, as a counter measures it, is often theatre. What it records as a lapse may have been a fork: the evenings went somewhere else, and the path was still a path. Something was being learned there, and it waited for us to come back with it.

Somewhere there is usually a folder we did not delete. A bookmark, a half-finished notebook, a tab that survived three computers. They are less a record than a promise we made without noticing, and they are easier to leave than to open. Coming back takes more deliberate effort than leaving did, and we tend to underestimate it until the evening arrives.

When we do open it, thirty years on, the subject is rarely where we left it, and neither are we. The part that once unsettled us, the part we skipped because we could not follow it, can now be gone over slowly, with nobody watching. Elsewhere we picked up some expertise, and it turns out to fit. The difficulty is still there, but it has become more interesting than frightening. We may even be in a position, at last, to be the person who says which part we still can’t explain.

The subject is rarely where we left it, and neither are we.

It is a privilege, and worth saying so. It takes an evening nobody else has claimed, a working machine, and a mind rested enough to be curious. Not everyone gets to return to what they set down. Those who do often find it more comfortable than they remembered, and not because the subject got easier. We stopped needing it to prove anything.

There are harder intervals. A difficult period can shrink the list of things we are able to care about in any practical way, and affection waits in messages we leave until tomorrow.

Something we once did for pleasure begins to require an amount of preparation that would have seemed absurd when we were well.

From inside such a period, six months is a long time. The prospect of an older self looking back on it with understanding is of limited use on a Thursday evening.

What helps, sometimes, is recognising the drift a few minutes earlier than we used to. The folder is still there. So is the interest, and there is still time to answer somebody.

People are the same kind of return. A friendship can go three years without a message and not feel any shorter for it, and then one evening someone answers, and the conversation resumes at roughly the volume it stopped. How often was never the measure. What mattered was that we stayed the kind of people who would answer. They have been somewhere else too, and they arrive with their own expertise, so getting to know them again is a second meeting, and a better informed one.

Human connection, friendship, love and intimacy keep a different kind of record. Nobody tracks it, and it would be spoiled by tracking, but over the years it adds up all the same: the meals made, the lifts given, the problems taken off someone’s evening, and the same coming back the other way. What accumulates is a life easier and warmer than a lonely one. Closeness is partly what that adds up to, felt from the inside.

Nobody tracks it, and it would be spoiled by tracking.

We take up an interest at ten, or twenty, or forty, or sixty, and discover that the people doing the most interesting work in it are young enough to have missed everything we remember. For a while there is the pleasure of being asked how things used to be done. There is another pleasure, once the questions turn in the other direction. An entire afternoon can still disappear into something unfamiliar. By now several people are inclined to regard this as entirely characteristic.

Perhaps one of them comes by later and asks how long we have been at it. We glance at the time in the corner of the screen and say, with some surprise, that we sat down just after lunch.

They meant in years. We have to think about that one.


Next essay

A Fork Is Still a Path: The Effort of Coming Back